Pages

Subscribe:

Ads 468x60px

Monday, 18 April 2016

Full docket for Canada’s first aboriginal Justice Minister

Her docket could hardly be any busier.

For Canada’s first aboriginal federal Justice Minister, the task ahead is replete with the immediate – marijuana legalization, promised changes to a terrorism bill and a framework for assisted suicide – and the longer-term, including a possible rollback of the Conservative government’s tough criminal laws that helped cause the indigenous population in federal jails to spike.

And if that were not enough, as Attorney-General, Jody Wilson-Raybould, 44, is tasked with advising the Prime Minister on legal issues across all of government. Which gives her influence over the reshaping of Canada’s relationship with its First Nations, one of Prime Minister Justin Trudeau’s stated priorities, on everything from land claims to education to policing.

And that could mean a shift from the federal government’s traditionally adversarial relationship on land claims and other issues, said John Borrows, the Canada Research Chair in Indigenous Law at the University of Victoria and a former professor of Ms. Wilson-Raybould’s.

“Right now, the litigation files often pit First Nations against the federal government. It’s fair to say that in most ... aboriginal title and treaty cases, the federal government is arrayed against the First Nations and Métis communities. She has options … it doesn’t always have to be on the oppositional side. It’s consistent with the role of the minister of justice to try to facilitate reconciliation and craft litigation opinions that go toward settlement as opposed to ending up in court.”

Josh Paterson, the executive director of the British Columbia Civil Liberties Association and a former First Nations lawyer, called the appointment “remarkable and important. For the statement to be made that the Crown justice representative, the leading law officer the Crown has, is going to be an indigenous person – that matters in and of itself.”

Ms. Wilson-Raybould is no stranger to busy dockets. As a provincial prosecutor at Vancouver’s Main Street courthouse in Vancouver from 2000 to 2003, at a time when local police were still laying charges for marijuana possession, she was involved when judges regularly dismissed criminal charges because of excessive delay.

She has been immersed in aboriginal issues since childhood, as the daughter of outspoken native leader Bill Wilson – who once told Pierre Trudeau that one of his daughters would be prime minister – and granddaughter of the late aboriginal elder Ethel Pearson. “The acorn doesn’t fall far from the tree – she’s part of a tradition of social responsibility,” said Terry La Liberté, a Vancouver criminal lawyer. She has been regional chief of the B.C. Assembly of First Nations since 2009, and before that a member of the B.C. Treaty Commission, overseeing treaty negotiations between aboriginals and the Crown.

Ms. Wilson-Raybould has been an elected councillor of the We Wai Kai Nation and lives in Cape Mudge Village on Quadra Island, according to a Liberal website. Her husband, Tim Raybould, a management consultant who has a PhD from Cambridge University in England, is Westbank First Nation’s chief negotiator for self-government, and senior policy adviser to the First Nations Finance Authority.

Eric Gottardi, a Vancouver defence lawyer, said Crown attorneys and the defence bar are pleased with the appointment. “She worked in the very busiest front-line courthouse that we have in this province.”

He said he expects her to be open to a greater emphasis on rehabilitation and restorative justice, including such measures as restoring the use of house arrest after the Conservatives banned it for more than 30 criminal offences.

Under the Conservatives, dozens of laws setting out mandatory minimum sentences were among those that pushed the aboriginal inmate population to 23.2 per cent in federal jails, although aboriginals make up just four per cent of Canadians. Other laws also fell hard on aboriginals, such as a victim surcharge that the Harper government made mandatory for all convicted criminals, no matter how poor. Aboriginal Canadians who committed mostly minor offences were at the heart of test cases on the law in several provinces.

Ghislain Picard, the Quebec chief of the Assembly of First Nations, applauded the appointment. “The indication Mr. Trudeau has seen fit to nominate one of our people in a very, very high-profile portfolio certainly indicates his willingness to strengthen the relationship with our peoples.”

William Trudell, the head of the Canadian Council of Criminal Defence Lawyers, said he expects an open, consultative approach that will include police, the Crown, judges and defence lawyers, and that will “enhance justice in this country and internationally.”

Mr. Paterson described Ms. Wilson-Raybould as “very smart. She listens. I think she is going to be very thoughtful about a whole range of changes made by the last government that negatively impacted people’s rights.”

Chief justice hammers 'gratuitous criticism'

Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke (left) and Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng at the press briefing on Wednesday. (Delwyn Verasamy. M&G)
The South African judiciary will meet with President Jacob Zuma to discuss the recent attacks on it, Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng told a media briefing on Wednesday.

“We will meet with the head of state to address repeated and unfounded criticism [of the judiciary],” Mogoeng announced at the briefing at a hotel at the OR Tambo airport on Wednesday. This followed an extraordinary judicial heads of court meeting

The criticism “has the potential to delegitimise the courts … [the law] should not be undermined” he said.

The comments were made following attacks by senior ANC leaders and its alliance partners on the judiciary.

A general disdain for the judiciary by some ANC members was heightened after the party was criticised for allowing Sudanese president Omar al-Bashir to leave the country. The International Criminal Court (ICC) had indicted Bashir, who was attending an African Union summit in South Africa, over war crimes and crimes against humanity. But government said it was just respecting its African obligations.

In the subsequent uproar and further court action over Bashir’s departure, ANC secretary general Gwede Mantashe accused the judiciary of “overreaching” and “contradicting the interest of the state versus judiciary”.

Minister of Police‚ Nkosinathi Nhleko‚ also said in June that some judges had met with people “to produce certain judgments”.

And the ANC Youth League and the South African Communist Party are allegedly going to organise mass protests against the “biased” judiciary.

Mogoeng told the gathering that “judges like others should be susceptible to criticism but it should be fair and in good faith”.

“It should be specific and clear … gratuitous criticism is unacceptable.”

Asked by members of the media about what the judiciary thinks of Mantashe and Nhleko’s comments, Mogoeng said the judiciary is not targeting a particular comment but just want to make a broad statement.

“Our intention is not to individualise our response to the situation … We will not go blow by blow with any personality.”

Asked what he hoped the meeting with Zuma would achieve, he said “the head of state is best placed to address issues that are raised”.

“We can’t pretend that nothing has been said because something has been said. One of the healthiest approaches to challenges that judges must adopt… [is to] raise those issues with the powers that be … behind closed doors and leave them to address them.”

He also raised concern over the disregard for court orders, but qualified this by saying only a few court orders have not been honoured by government.

“The concern in our statement must be coupled with the reality that only… [a] few court orders have not been honoured by government.

Deep reflection

“Because we are only aware of one eyebrow-raising apparent disregard for a court order … we believe that this meeting and our concerns that have been raised are strong enough to discourage anyone who was thinking of disregarding court orders, to think twice.”

He said he didn’t think this was a moment of crisis for the judiciary but a moment “for deep reflection, brutal self-introspections, institutional introspection”.

“I will not try to anticipate what the president responds. But I am confident that he will reflect on what is happening now and [what is in] our statement… and deal with the engagement with a seriousness with which it deserves.”

While Mogoeng spoke, SACP president Blade Nzimande announced at the party’s congress in Soweto that the media must respect “our views” to criticise the judiciary. He went on to say that criticising those who attack the judiciary was ideological blackmail which needed to be fought.
Other members of the legal fraternity also attended the meeting.

Busani Mabunda, co-chair of the Law Society of South Africa and president of the Black Lawyers Association, told the Mail & Guardian that “it is incumbent upon the profession to stand up and talk to these issues and spare the judiciary from assuming this role”.

Gcina Malindi, advocate at Advocates for Transformation, said the fraternity agreed with Mogoeng “who has indicated that if there are criticisms they have to be specific and they have to be clear”.

“We agree that the judiciary is not beyond criticism but gratuitous criticism and attacks on the judiciary do not strengthen democratic principles ... It undermines democracy and the judiciary.”